Blogdorf Goodman is a mishmash of beauty product reviews, musings on fashion and swooning over fragrances.

Thursday, May 17, 2007


Questions to Blogdorf: Waterproof Mascara

Molly from Florida needs a mascara that is waterproof that will give her volume. She wants a full lash without a mess.

I have a mascara dilemma and I travel counter to counter and can't seem to solve it but I thought your and your team at BG might be able to help. I love the look that Dior Maximeyes gives my lashes -- fuller as though there are more individual lashes but still soft (no spider legs). I don't want them longer, just fuller. But it doesn't come in waterproof and I use eyedrops for contacts about every hour or so (so I really need wp).

She has tried layering with no success.
If you have any recs or ideas let us know in the comments.

posted by Annieytown @ 6:02 AM   18 Inspired Comments

18 Inspired Comments:

At 5:15 AM, Blogger txteva said...

For me Bare Escentuals i.d Weather Everything Waterproof Mascara is tops.
Hands down... this lasts forever, never flakes and is really gentle on the lashes.

 
At 8:15 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

How about Lancome Hypnose in waterproof? Also, how about Max Factor Volume Couture in waterproof?

 
At 9:03 AM, Blogger GablesGirl said...

Eva and Anon -- Thanks so much! I have not tried the BE or Hypnose. I'll give them a try!!

Annie -- You are wonderful to post and get me help! Thanks again! Love love love the blog! You are the only one I check daily -- and you make BG is so worth it!! Molly

 
At 11:28 AM, Blogger katiedid said...

My sis is really enamored of Bourjois' Pump up the Volume one - and her eyes are fairly sensitive from seasonal allergies (well, mostly only at this time of year) and wearing contacts. I rather liked the effect the Smashbox lash primer had for giving a bit of water-resistance to my regular mascara (the YSL Volume) but that's a bit of extra trouble to go to, which may be annoying to some folks.

 
At 11:58 AM, Blogger Diet Pepsi Girl said...

If you're interested in sticking with your preferred mascara, Urban Decay makes something called Lingerie and Galoshes for lashes. One end is a primer (with fibers), the other end is a waterproofer. It's clear and won't weigh down your lashes.
Just a thought :)
Claire

 
At 1:15 PM, Blogger Beauty Alchemist said...

I have had troubles with mascras for ages. I can really put them thru there paces. When Cover Girl went to a smudge free formula years ago, they worked really well. never ran. they triple aquastay was great, but the new exact ones work super too.
also, I haven't tried it yet, but Chanel has Imitable in waterproof.

The Bourjois mentioned earlier are super as well. Good luck

 
At 1:36 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

As a contacts-wearing gal, I feel your pain. I didn't wear mascara for years (luckily, my lashes are pretty nice naturally) until... last year. I like Blinc's Kiss Me mascara a LOT. It's a little tricky to put on, but it won't come off until you want it to.

Of course, for a cheaper alternative, Covergirl's Lash Exact now comes in a nice waterproof formula and the brush really does work well.

 
At 2:36 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Max Factor 2000 Calorie Waterproof! It is amazing.

 
At 2:43 PM, Blogger GablesGirl said...

Katie: I haven't been to the Bourjois counter in a long time. Wonderful reason to check it back out!

Diet: A primer and wp in one tube?! Be still my heart! Thanks!

Alchem: Love your blog too! My DH thanks you for reminding me about drugstore options ;] (now off to the Chanel counter!!).

You chicas rock!! Molly

 
At 4:46 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Good question! I haven't found one either. My other problem with mascara is I curl my lashes and then when I put the mascara on lashes all go straight and so once the mascara dries I have to curl them again which I think makes the mascara flake. Anyone else have this problem?

 
At 9:09 PM, Blogger Unknown said...

How about something like Kiss Me Mascara that creates tubules is waterproof and never flakes.

 
At 7:12 AM, Blogger Annieytown said...

Thanks everybody for the recs!

 
At 7:15 AM, Blogger Annieytown said...

Anon: I have the same problem. I have poker straight lashes that resist all curling techniques.
The best mascaras I have used is Max Factor's Volume Couture and Chanel's Inimitable.

 
At 8:50 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I feel your PAIN! I have the same problem with straight lashes. This morning, I curled my lashes & used Max Factor Volume Couture. I'm looking in the mirror now & my lashes still look straight. What do you do?

Do you recurl lashes after mascara dries? It sticks to the eyelash curler & I am afraid I will lose all my eyelashes.

 
At 12:21 AM, Blogger Principal Investigator said...

I like WP Lancome Hypnose, except it's a little flaky, if I rub my eyes. Otherwise, loads of volume and doesn't budge. What I've been using lately is Lancome lash primer and Tarte's Lights, Camera, Splashes (which has kitschy-cute denim packaging). My lashes are full (Hypnose, still has more volume), but natural-ish and doesn't smudge for a very long time (again, I'm an eye-rubber). Am not a fan of Urban Decay's double ended thing. The top coat was goopily wet and the basecoat was much too fibrous to be of use.

 
At 8:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Just thought I would add my "can't live without" waterproofer...It's Clarins mascara sealer. It is not thick or goopy, application is a breeze, and it is totally invisible. Since I put mascara on my bottow lashes, I apply the sealer to the top AND bottom of my lower lashes..works like a charm!! Available at my home away from home...Saks! Barb

 
At 10:27 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

what is the best curling mascara out there?

 
At 8:58 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi out there! Someone said earlier "try Max Factor waterproof Volume Couture mascara" to a person looking for a good waterproof mascara. I've been looking for that specific waterproof mascara all week and can only find it in the regular formula. Anyone know where I can get the waterproof version? I live in Boca raton FL. Thanks! A.T.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

About Me

My Photo
Name: Annieytown
Location: Ytown, Ohio, United States

I am not involved with Bergdorf Goodman except as a smitten fan and customer. My contact information is: annieytown@yahoo.com

View my complete profile

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    Previous Posts

    • The tones of gray, pale turquoise and pink will pr...
    • Covergirl's True Blend Whipped FoundationThis $8.0...
    • Items worth noting in May's issue of AllurePage 44...
    • Fragrance of the Day: Guerlain's ChamadeI fell in ...
    • LA DuWop Event Where: American Legion HollywoodWhe...
    • Marilyn Manson is a Nars fanFrom an interview wit...
    • Spring Cleaning
    • Trip over love, you can get up. Fall in love and y...
    • CoverGirl's Trueblend Luminous Loose Blush Powder ...
    • New Dior Eye Show and Pro CheekWe were visiting Sa...

    Powered by Blogger


     

    site stats